UPDATE: It seems that Lumen database has finally acknowledged that there is an issue and seen the light. Its operators have announced an important change, limiting access to actual infringing links. Per Torrent Freak:
In a nutshell, takedown notices presented in Lumen’s database will no longer list the precise URLs targeted by copyright holders. Instead, as the image below illustrates, the notices only list how many URLs were targeted at specific domains.
I’ve written about the Lumen, formerly “chilling effects” DMCA database in the past and how it “makes a mockery of the DMCA.” I’ve also pointed out that the site provides a repository for links to to pirated downloads and streams even after they’ve been reported for copyright infringement. Now, with the release of a new browser extension for Chrome and Opera, the database’s questionable practices are in the spotlight once more. The extension, aptly anointed “Google Unlocked,” makes it easy for users to once to bypass takedowns and once again use the search engine to find pirated links to their favorite movies. Its developers claim:
The extension scans hidden links that were censored on Google search results due to complaints. The tool scans those complaints and extracts the links from them, puts the links back into Google results, all in a matter of seconds.
Why are removed links still available online?
When Google removes a link reported for infringement from in its search results it conveniently (for would-be pirates) replaces the removed material with a disclaimer that, in turn, features a link to the original DMCA notice (on Lumendatabase.org) which includes infringing URLs.
Below is an example found today when searching for Captain Marvel downloads on Google.
Notice the Lumen link . Clicking that leads to the original DMCA notice and the list of reported infringing links which, when I chose one randomly, led me to an actual pirated download of the film. Piracy lives!
However, using this extension makes even such rudimentary mouse clicks moot. Basically it seems to, for all intents and purposes, undo Google’s tepid effort to comply with the DMCA. Since operators of Lumen Database refuse to redact any portion of the infringing URLs found in the DMCA notices in its database, this new extension easily restores the pirate links. According to Torrent Freak:
Since by its very nature the tool searches for allegedly infringing links, we aren’t going to demonstrate those here. Safe to say, however, the tool does scan LumenDatabase as advertised and all the removed links do get embedded in the search result page itself, very large numbers of links in some instances.
Lumen provides pirate links with eternal life online
Several years ago I actually tried to bring further attention to this problem by sending Lumen (then Chilling Effects) Database a DMCA notice for my own film. We went through the usual song and dance. I sent the notice, they sent a counter-notice, and when I couldn’t go to court to enforce the takedown, the DMCA notice containing the pirate links went be online. As a creator with no bevy of lawyers at my disposal, I had no alternative and I knew it. I did it to raise awareness.
I even raised this issue in front of various industry stakeholders (including Google) at a 2016 U.S. Copyright Section 512 roundtable discussion in San Francisco. Here’s part of what I said at the the time:
Google removes the link from the search results, yet provides a link to the document that actually has the same link in it. So it may be following the letter of the law. But I don’t think it follows the spirit of the law. And I’m not suggesting that the Lumen Database shouldn’t exist. I think it’s important and I know Berkeley Law used that extensively in their most recent study. But what I would suggest is maybe using technology to redact a little bit of the URL. And researchers who really want to go and look at the information could go to Lumen and actually get the DMCA notice. But it doesn’t need to be so convenient that a user looking for pirated content can find it so easily.
Per usual, my remarks were ignored and the LumenDatabase.org continued its dubious practice of listing all the infringing links in full. Perhaps this new extension, Google Unlocked, will cause some to rethink this approach and pay close attention to Google’s sleight of hand when it comes to compliance with the DMCA. Hey, how about revisiting the DMCA entirely while we’re at it? A girl can dream…..